Menu of Poker Alice in Lake City, Colorado, USA

Menu Overview

Located in the heart of Lake City, Colorado, Poker Alice offers a genuine slice of mountain-town charm alongside its renowned pizza menu. This pizzeria, nestled at 188 Gunnison Ave, has earned its reputation through a blend of rustic ambiance and hearty, flavorful dishes that satisfy both locals and travelers alike.

The menu at Poker Alice shines brightest with its classic and generously sized pizzas. Customers frequently praise the large pies, noting that they easily feed a family or a group of hungry teens, making it an ideal spot for communal dining. Each pizza boasts a rich balance of fresh, quality ingredients — from robust tomato sauce and melty cheese to well-seasoned toppings — that come together to deliver a comforting, satisfying bite. The dough strikes a pleasing harmony between crisp edges and a tender center, highlighting the skill baked into every crust.

Beyond pizza, the calzones are a hidden gem mentioned repeatedly by returning guests. With golden, perfectly folded crusts encasing savory fillings, they provide a delicious alternative for those seeking variety. Furthermore, Poker Alice serves an equally commendable breakfast and a selection of sandwiches, expanding its appeal beyond traditional lunchtime fare. The coffee complements the breakfast offerings well, enhancing the overall experience with its smooth, warming profile.

The restaurant’s indoor space is cozy and intimate—marked by a rustic, small-town aesthetic that makes every visit feel personal. However, the true delight lies in its outdoor seating area, allowing diners to savor their meals while immersed in the fresh mountain air and scenic views of the San Juan range. This feature resonates deeply with visitors, especially those who appreciate dining al fresco in a tranquil setting.

While the service is consistently friendly and attentive, it’s important to note that during busy times, waits can be longer than expected. Nonetheless, patrons agree that the quality of food justifies the delay, with every slice and bite reaffirming the value of patience. Occasional quirks, like a non-functional soda machine, add to the local character and charm of this establishment rather than diminish it.

In summary, Poker Alice’s menu delivers a classic yet authentic pizza experience, enhanced by generous portions, thoughtful preparation, and a welcoming atmosphere that feels distinctly local. Whether craving a large pizza after a day exploring the mountains or a cozy breakfast to start the morning, this venue remains a highly recommended gem in Lake City’s culinary landscape.